Post by Brian SmithPost by QuestorPost by Loren PechtelOn Thu, 11 Jan 2018 06:44:50 -0500, shawn
Post by shawnOn Wed, 10 Jan 2018 20:20:28 -0800 (PST), Brian Smith
Post by Brian SmithPost by Bob CotterI was just going to post how totally unfair this task was too.
Hopefully that was a one-time only thing never to be done again.
Agreed. All it took was one team with two weak players to end up being
eliminated. That team came awfully close to being eliminated because
neither one was physically strong/fast enough to be able to win
against the other teams. While the guy could have done better by not
trying to cut so many corners I still don't think that would have let
him win against the other racers to which he lost.
It's a physical challenge. A team of two weak players is going to do
badly at many physical challenges. I don't see that it's unfair. Team
Yale doesn't have a chance in the long run.
Maybe Brian would have prefered it if instead the task was to differentiate
trigonometric equations or conjugate Latin verbs. Or perhaps to eat three
raw duck embryos covered in Belgian chocolate. [sfx: Survivor horn/theme]
1. The course was too tight which allowed physically bigger teams to either
block or cutoff smaller teams. The only reason Cody beat the NBA guy is b/c
the NBA guy was TOO big.
I can't agree. A smaller person could just as easily block a larger person. It
was more important to be quick, to get out in front.
Post by Brian Smith2. According to the Goat who ran the course each bag of fries weighed about
20 pounds which meant they had to push around 160+ pounds of weight. How is
that fair?
How is that not fair? They all had the same weight. Again, I point to the
roadblock from last season pedalling bicycles overloaded with fishtraps. There
have always been physical tasks.
Post by Brian Smith3. Doing this task at the mat essentially made the rest of leg a waste. Having
more chances to run the task was not necessarily a benefit of getting to
the mat early. What was more important was who you got paired up against.
Has nothing to do with being fair... and the so-called "bunching points" have
long had the same effect.
Post by Brian Smith4. Being last to the mat in the leg meant nothing. This twist was so ridiculous
that the firefighter twins could have arrived 6 hours after the Goats
and still advanced to the next leg.
Again, no connection to fairness.
It all comes down to being better at a task -- a silly footrace -- than other
teams. A team that wasn't better than any other team -- in other words, the
worst team -- would be eliminated. TAR isn't just about travel racing. Teams
must also be good at completing the various tasks (detours, roadblocks, etc.).
Post by Brian SmithPost by QuestorI'm not even sure how Goat Yoga fits into the theme of 'most competitive.'
I think they were a weak team and wouldn't have gotten far in the race. If it
wasn't this little physical contest, then it would have been another task where
racers have to climb, carry, or move something.
What would have killed them was the constant bickering which seems to still
be happening today. Hard to believe they've been business partners for 20
years. They're also not the only team that doesn't fit into the most competitive.
In addition to Goat Yoga and Big Brother, the twin EMTs, the musicians, and
the Ring Girls all have little or no apparent tie to the theme of being the most
competitive. I know lifeguards take their competitions seriously, but while I
don't doubt there are EMT competitions, we haven't been shown that the twins
are active and/or excel in such. Music can certainly be a competitive business,
but musicians don't really compete against each other in the same way as the
others.